Shareholder agreements in China

Shareholder Agreement in China is a topic that is becoming increasingly important for international investors and entrepreneurs who decide to work in the promising Asian market. Every year, the number of foreign companies and individuals planning to open their own business in China increases. But not everyone takes into account the requirements for drawing up shareholder agreements in China, which differ from the usual Western or European standards. But it is precisely such nuances that can affect the quality of control over the business and the protection of the interests of the owners. Such a legal structure is becoming a key tool that helps to streamline relations between company participants and avoid conflicts in the implementation of statutory goals.

Reasons for the need for a Shareholders Agreement in Chinese jurisdiction

The importance of forming an agreement between shareholders (or stakeholders) becomes especially noticeable when it comes to foreign investors in China. Registering a company may seem like a simple formality on paper, but local legislation is structured in such a way that without a detailed shareholders' agreement it is very difficult to properly protect the interests of the parties. If the founders do not plan to formalize the management mechanisms in detail, then any disagreements subsequently risk developing into unforeseen losses.

It often happens that partners from other countries plan to conduct business in accordance with the usual principles. They believe that the standard charter covers all issues: determining the competence of management bodies, distribution of shares, voting procedure. But in China, the approach to corporate affairs differs significantly from Western standards. Local law enforcement practice implies that only the presence of clearly defined mechanisms for resolving internal conflicts allows one to avoid serious disagreements. That is why the development of a Shareholder Agreement in China is not just a formality, but a necessary business strategy.

Among other things, concluding a detailed partnership agreement helps to take into account fiscal features. regulations for the redistribution of profits, as well as issues of attracting additional capital. Investors who have taken care in advance to draw up an agreement between shareholders in China taking into account all legal subtleties can avoid the mistakes typical of those who rely only on general corporate law. The presence of a separate document increases trust between the parties and provides foreign participants with additional guarantees of stable business conduct.

The formal rules of the charter naturally regulate the basic procedures, but it does not always provide answers to questions that arise when internal corporate conflicts arise. To do this, it is important to conclude agreements between shareholders in China and, if possible, to spell out all the essential conditions in as much detail as possible. Such a document often turns out to be a decisive argument in controversial situations, since the court or arbitration authority takes into account mutual obligations recorded in writing. And the ability to refer to specific points of the agreement creates an additional level of protection for all parties.

In the context of the Chinese corporate environment, there are several key factors that demonstrate why the basic charter does not guarantee sufficient protection of interests. In real conditions, only a separate agreement can provide an agreed mechanism for the distribution of powers and clarify the responsibilities of shareholders. This is especially important for foreign investors who are encountering the Chinese corporate governance system for the first time. Without comprehensive internal documents, the risk of losing control over the company's activities or facing opaque decisions from partners increases significantly.

List of main factors requiring signing a comprehensive agreement:

1. The need for detailed regulation of the rights and obligations of the parties (the charter reflects only general points).
2. Protection of investments from unexpected changes in development strategy on the part of local partners.
3. Guarantee of a transparent mechanism for the distribution of profits and dividends.
4. Formalization of the procedure for resolving disagreements and disputes without resorting to general corporate legislation.
5. Developing mechanisms to protect minority shareholders, which is important when the shareholding is not equal.

Given these factors, every foreigner planning to participate in the capital of a Chinese company is interested in having shareholder agreements drawn up at the highest level. Do not limit yourself to the minimum. An initial investment in detailed setting of parameters is more profitable than subsequent resolution of legal disputes. A thorough preparation of a shareholders' agreement in the PRC is a reliable basis for a sustainable enterprise. The role of this provision is enhanced when there are several parties making investments.

The legal nature of the shareholders' agreement in China and its significance for business practice

A careful study of the norms of corporate legislation in China makes it clear. The document signed by the owners of shares is not a formal act, but a full-fledged management tool. In essence, this agreement is the result of an agreement between the owners of the company on management mechanisms, the procedure for making key decisions and ways to protect investments. Chinese legislation does not regulate in detail the content of such acts, which gives participants a certain freedom. However, it is precisely this freedom that requires careful study and knowledge of legal norms.

When investors decide to develop a Shareholder Agreement in China, they actually take on the task of formulating all organizational, managerial and financial rules. Unlike some Western jurisdictions, where law enforcement practice has already been worked out for years, the Chinese market is still developing. Accordingly, any gaps in the agreement can be interpreted ambiguously. If shareholders want to ensure clarity and prevent conflict situations, it is necessary to take into account that the Shareholder Agreement in China establishes not only internal rules, but also certain principles of interaction with external counterparties.

In practice, it is the preparation of a shareholder agreement in China that becomes the key moment in forming the distribution of functions between managers. Various aspects are specified here, such as quorum requirements for making important decisions, criteria for acceptable investments, the procedure for changing the capital structure, and methods for resolving disputes. Without these points, each shareholder may be tempted to act in unilateral interests or even block initiatives that are important for business development.

The importance of this document is especially high in situations where foreign participants are part of the founders. They often need additional legal certainty. A well-written structure of a shareholder agreement in China helps to avoid misunderstandings that arise due to differences in mentality, language barriers or cultural traditions of doing business. Moreover, given the rapid transformation of the local legal field, only individually developed conditions allow you to remain within the legal field, guaranteeing the interests of all parties.

Legal differences between a company's incorporation document and a Shareholders' Agreement in China

The company charter in China, unlike the shareholders' agreement, is an official document required for state registration of a legal entity. It reflects basic information about the company: name, legal address, size of the authorized capital, procedure for forming management bodies. At the same time, the Shareholder Agreement in China has a much more flexible structure and allows for in-depth recording of specific agreements between business partners. The charter, in essence, is oriented towards government agencies and contains information necessary for formal registration.

In China, there are provisions that cannot be included in the charter, but they are extremely important for day-to-day operations and the protection of participants’ rights. This may include mechanisms for profit distribution, features of share transfers, and details on withdrawal from the membership. If such mechanisms are included in a public registration document, it will be accessible to third parties, which is not always desirable. At the same time, provisions when drafting a shareholder agreement in China allow for maximum detail on issues that remain outside the scope of public information. This ensures confidentiality and protects sensitive business data.

Often, the development of a shareholder agreement in China is based on the need to add flexible project management tools that cannot be included in the charter due to the fact that Chinese law strictly regulates certain aspects of the corporate structure. Additional rights and obligations of participants, the procedure for resolving possible conflicts, the distribution of management roles - all this is placed in a separate document that retains its legal force in relation to the parties. As a result, each participant understands why additional agreements are needed and what obligations they bear.

List of key differences that cannot be included in the articles of association but are important to include in the shareholders agreement in China:

1. Detailed procedure for making dividend payments and reinvesting profits.
2. Mechanisms for resolving corporate disputes and distribution of responsibility.
3. Conditions for blocking votes and veto rights for individual groups of shareholders.
4. Step-by-step procedure for withdrawal from membership and compensation payment procedure.
5. Additional restrictions on the transfer of shares to third parties and regulation of changes in control.

All of the above points are important in forming a balanced management system within the company. It is precisely due to the precise formulation of each provision in a separate document that full protection of the interests of the parties is achieved. If this is reflected only in the charter, gaps inevitably arise that create the ground for future misunderstandings.

Legal force of shareholders agreement in China

The PRC legal framework on corporate issues is quite comprehensive, but not always unambiguous. At the same time, the courts consider the existence of an agreement on the procedure for exercising shareholders' rights as a weighty argument in resolving conflicts if this document is drawn up in accordance with the requirements of the law. When the parties decide to enter into an agreement between shareholders in China, they thereby create a mutual obligation to act within the agreed terms. However, the question of the possibility of enforcement remains: in what cases will the court recognize certain clauses of the agreement in full?

In Chinese law, it is customary to adhere to such principles as good faith and respect for the public interest. If the text of the agreement does not contradict mandatory norms, then the document is recognized as valid. In turn, if some points infringe on public order or clearly contradict the laws, then the court may refuse to apply them. A carefully prepared Shareholder Agreement in China will help to avoid misunderstandings regarding the validity of individual provisions.

It is also important to remember the issues of choice of jurisdiction. Sometimes investors consider the possibility of including an arbitration clause in favor of international instances. This may be useful if the parties are concerned about the complexity of legal proceedings in China. However, when conducting transactions within the PRC, recourse to territorial courts becomes inevitable. Therefore, including a detailed procedure for resolving disputes in the agreement of capital participants acts as a clear instruction for the participants in the process and law enforcement. Determining the jurisdiction authorized to consider possible claims is of critical importance.

Any questions?

Contact our specialists

Send your application

Overview of the structure of a typical Shareholder Agreement in China

Before signing a document, entrepreneurs need to consider a wide range of issues. In practice, a shareholder agreement sets fundamental standards - from the list of rights of shareholders to the algorithm for distributing profits. The document serves as an internal charter, logically complementing the registration agreement. Its key task is to form a management system and a reliable legal basis that is understandable to all participants. For this reason, the text of the agreement traditionally opens with provisions on the procedure for forming the board of directors or other management team. Such a clause affects the number of seats, the procedure for their distribution and the grounds for recalling representatives. Next come sections related to the legal status of shareholders, their responsibilities in matters of financing and compliance with the agreed development strategy. The development of clear mechanisms for coordinating the budget and individual large transactions minimizes the risk of unauthorized conduct of business by any of the participants.

It is equally important to include blocks related to confidentiality and non-competition. It is known that the high-tech sector is developing intensively in China, and the secrecy of know-how comes to the fore. Therefore, it is the content of the Shareholder Agreement in China that can distinguish between what information can be disclosed and what must be kept secret. Also, the agreement on the procedure for exercising shareholders' rights must provide for punishment for violating the confidentiality regime. In the case of considering provisions establishing restrictions on competitive activity, it is prescribed in which industries, regions or market segments the shareholder does not have the right to create such a business.

Below is an indicative list of sections that it would be advisable to include in a shareholder agreement:

• corporate administration system;
• powers and responsibilities of shareholders;
• algorithm for placing attachments;
• regulations for voting and approval of resolutions;
• protection of classified information and restrictions on competitive activities;
• procedure for disposal and alienation of shares;
• the procedure for distributing profits among participants;
• priority for acquisition of shares;
• conflict resolution tools.

Each of these elements must be spelled out in sufficient detail so that the parties understand how to act in different scenarios. Any overlooked detail can lead to protracted disagreements, which is especially relevant when interacting with participants with different cultural backgrounds and value orientations. The higher the complexity of the project, the longer the process of agreeing on the interests of the parties. But the result is long-term investment security and normal functioning of the company.

How to draft a shareholder agreement in China taking into account the Chinese corporate governance model

Drafting a document that is adapted to the local legal system is not an easy task. First of all, it is necessary to take into account the peculiarities of decision-making in China. Traditionally, local companies attach great importance to internal hierarchy and collective approval. An agreement between shareholders in China should be prepared so that its provisions reflect local legal specifics. The rigid corporate management model common in Western jurisdictions functions differently within this country.

When drafting a joint venture agreement, it is useful for the parties to rely on mixed procedures for approving key decisions. In particular, a system can be introduced that allows for the position of key majority shareholders to be taken into account, while at the same time preserving certain privileges for minority shareholders. Such a balance is achieved by spelling out clear quorum conditions, as well as blocking rights. Each party receives some authority, but cannot single-handedly determine the fate of the company without the consent of the others. This is especially important in the case of foreign investors, who cannot always be on site and personally control the business.

Particular attention should be paid to the structuring of a shareholder agreement in China, including the distribution of shares and the determination of the degree of involvement in management. Lawyers recommend specifying specific job positions and powers, including the right to sign certain types of contracts or banking documents. In addition, it is important to stipulate issues of information exchange so that each party has access to current financial reports and forecasts. If there is a need to influence the company's strategy, the procedure for submitting proposals should be as clear as possible.

Finally, the process of text approval cannot be ignored. Local laws governing partnerships imply that the legal preparation of a shareholders' agreement in China must be based on the principles of good faith and mutual respect. Unilateral provisions that severely limit the rights of the other party risk being challenged in court. Ultimately, only a thorough legal analysis of each section and articles of the agreement helps. Expert support plays a significant role in the development of a shareholders' agreement in the People's Republic of China. It is provided by specialized advisers who thoroughly understand local intricacies and are able to build a legal structure taking into account national traditions and regulatory requirements.

Action algorithm: Registration of a Shareholders Agreement in China

Most businessmen want to understand how the preparation of a Shareholder Agreement in China is carried out in practice. Once the parties understand the need to protect their interests through a written agreement, they need to develop a common strategy. At this stage, a basic consultation with local lawyers familiar with Chinese law is usually carried out and the financial aspects of the future project are worked out. It is also important to determine who will be responsible for administering the transaction and collecting all the necessary information. Below is a guide to drafting a Shareholder Agreement in China.

It is then important to ensure timely fulfillment of the fixed conditions. The parties are obliged to make the necessary contributions to the authorized capital, vote according to the agreed procedure and adhere to the established regulations. If someone evades obligations, then sanctions are provided.

Specifics of shareholder agreements when establishing an enterprise with foreign capital

In a significant proportion of cases, foreign investors participate in the creation of local companies with the status of FIE (Foreign-Invested Enterprise). This legal regime expands export potential and facilitates commercial activities, while imposing additional obligations. When preparing a shareholder agreement for a Chinese organization, it should be taken into account that specialized supervisory authorities pay increased attention to companies with foreign capital. Any inaccuracy or discrepancy in the constituent set can lead to an unscheduled inspection.

For example, FIE structures often operate in the fields of trade, manufacturing and IT. Local legislation imposes increased requirements on them regarding the formation of management bodies, the procedure for making foreign investments and repatriation of profits. Therefore, when describing the terms of a shareholder agreement in China, it is necessary to include mechanisms that comply with the rules on capital turnover and currency control. If these aspects are missed, the transfer of dividends outside the country may be delayed or face formal restrictions from Chinese regulators.

Investors should also take into account that it is especially important for them to include in the Shareholder Agreement in China the procedure for settling possible disputes. If the project is primarily focused on exports or cooperation with foreign companies, a clause on international arbitration can be included. However, if the business is entirely concentrated within China, it is more logical to indicate local jurisdiction. In this case, the parties adapt the agreement to the specifics of the Chinese legal order. The content of the shareholder agreement in China should take into account not only the general provisions on cooperation, but also regulate financial flows, the profit sharing system and other aspects important for organizations with foreign capital.

Confidentiality and non-competition: Protecting your business via a Shareholders Agreement

When entering the Chinese market, many companies value their unique technologies and business models. Local specifics include high competition and intensive information exchange. When establishing a company in the People's Republic of China, a shareholder agreement should be drawn up taking into account the requirements of confidentiality. This is achieved by including in the contract a detailed section defining the list of information that the participants undertake not to disclose. Such data includes customer bases, technological processes, and pricing algorithms.

An equally important section is the clause on the inadmissibility of competing activity. If any partner attempts to launch a similar project or poach key personnel, the company will suffer economic losses. To prevent such a risk, the parties sign an agreement that sets out the exact terms and territorial limits of abstinence from competing initiatives. In this way, the partners guarantee that their joint venture will not face a sudden increase in competitors from its own environment.

In order to legally execute a Shareholder Agreement in China, it is necessary to ensure that the non-competition and confidentiality provisions do not conflict with the norms of Chinese law. For example, some regions have special rules governing labor relations and freedom of entrepreneurship. On the other hand, adequately drafted sections oblige participants to maintain silence about commercial information and not to negatively affect the overall business, which becomes a guarantee of security for shareholders.

The legal structure dedicated to maintaining confidentiality and preventing competitive actions ensures long-term protection of investments and ideas that are brought into the joint business. As a result, the parties can develop the company without fear that their developments will become the property of third parties. And additional sanctions for violations of these provisions encourage all participants to strictly adhere to the rules.

Dispute resolution mechanisms in drafting Shareholders Agreement in China

Even with carefully agreed wording, internal corporate disputes cannot be ruled out. When parties disagree, it is essential that they have a transparent mechanism for resolution. In the context of this topic, liability for breach of the terms of the shareholders' agreement in China plays a special role: if the document clearly defines the sanctions for failure to fulfill obligations, this can encourage the partners to reach a peaceful solution.

When a dispute arises, many entrepreneurs try to resolve the issue in a Chinese court. But the procedure can be quite lengthy, and not all judges are familiar with the complexities of international business. In some cases, it is advisable to provide for international arbitration, for example, the Singapore International Arbitration Centre or Hong Kong Arbitration. If the business is mainly within China, then local arbitration commissions can also help. Before preparing a shareholder agreement as part of business registration in the PRC, it is necessary to determine which judicial or arbitration institution will be empowered to resolve conflicts in order to avoid contradictions in the issue of jurisdiction.

Examples of dispute resolution clauses commonly found in shareholder agreements include:

1. Mandatory negotiation process and mediation before initiating legal proceedings.
2. Timeframes allotted for attempts at a peaceful settlement.
3. Selection of a specific arbitration institution or judicial body.
4. Prescribed fines or compensation for failure to comply with the decision.
5. Agreed standards for the presentation of evidence and expert opinions.

Once such a section is included in the Shareholder Agreement in China, the agreement takes on a more practical sound. The parties understand how to act in controversial situations and how exactly to calculate potential losses. This contributes to early conflict prevention and strengthens the overall trust within the collective of owners. If all members of the company recognize the legitimacy of the chosen method of settlement, then any issue can be resolved within the framework of agreed procedures, preventing escalation and disruption of business relations.

Fixing in the agreement the conditions of redemption, termination of membership and change of shareholder

In the course of business activities, there may be situations in which one of the co-owners seeks to cease participation in the business or expand its share by buying out shares. Such changes can seriously affect the activities of the entire company. In such a situation, assistance in drafting a shareholder agreement in China plays a key role, since it is necessary to take into account many legal and financial nuances. This is especially true in cases where the parties have different citizenships and mentalities.

One of the most common tools here is the buyout option, which allows shareholders to determine in advance the procedure and cost of buying out a share if a partner decides to leave the project. Deadlock clauses can also be included, which describe what to do if the board of directors reaches a deadlock on important strategic issues. By providing for such mechanisms, shareholders free themselves from chaotic negotiations in difficult moments: all the rules are already fixed in the agreement.

Sometimes a put/call option is used, where one party has the right (but not the obligation) to sell or buy shares according to a pre-agreed formula. This is useful when restructuring a business or when a legally significant conflict of interests arises between the participants. If an agreement between co-owners of a company registered in China is concluded without taking such points into account, the result may be a lawsuit with an uncertain outcome or a forced sale of a share on unfavorable terms.

Examples of legal instruments used when changing a controlling party:

1. Buyout-clause: a pre-agreed procedure for buying out a share.
2. Deadlock mechanisms: rules of action when it is impossible to make a decision.
3. Put/call option: the right to sell or buy shares at fixed parameters.
4. Prohibition on transfer of shares without notification of other participants.
5. Conditions of corporate control and the procedure for changing management bodies.

Such provisions are necessary to maintain stability in the company. If a major investor wants to leave the project, it is important for the remaining participants to be able to retain control and value of the business. On the contrary, if a partner wants to increase his share, it is worth describing the logic of such a transaction in advance. Pre-agreed rules help not only to maintain trust, but also to carry out the necessary operations without significant losses for all interested parties.

Mistakes when drafting a shareholders agreement in China

Even experienced specialists sometimes make mistakes that cost all participants dearly. The main rule is to prepare a constituent agreement between shareholders when establishing a company in China taking into account the specifics of the local legal field, and not rely on templates from other jurisdictions. As practice shows, many simply translate a standard agreement and believe that this is sufficient for legal force. But Chinese law has its own peculiarities, and without taking them into account, you can face legal vulnerability.

Shareholders sometimes forget about the specifics of currency control. When planning dividends or investments, it is important to indicate how mutual settlements and transfers of funds abroad will be made. Another mistake is the lack of clearly defined sanctions for failure to fulfill obligations, including deadlines for fulfilling obligations. When such clauses are absent, it is difficult for the court or arbitration to assess the amount of compensation, which makes the protection of the rights of participants weak.

Mistakes when drafting a shareholder agreement in China:

1. Using "universal" templates without adaptation to Chinese legislation.
2. Vague wording regarding responsibilities and deadlines.
3. Skipping sections on confidentiality and non-compete.
4. Ignoring currency restrictions and capital repatriation rules.
5. Underestimating conflict resolution procedures.

To minimize risks, it is necessary to determine in advance the elements to be included in the agreement between the participants when establishing a company in the People's Republic of China. Such aspects include a precise distribution of powers on the board of directors, detailed restrictions on competing activities, and strict rules for the protection of official secrets.

Ignoring even one of these provisions is fraught with significant economic losses and loss of business reputation. Therefore, careful study of each section taking into account Chinese legislation is the only way to guarantee the smooth functioning of business in the country.

Conclusion

A well-thought-out drafting of a shareholders' agreement prepared in China forms a reliable framework for the implementation of any commercial projects. When founders approach the issue formally, relying only on the charter, this can result in unwanted conflicts or the dilution of the interests of individual partners. Therefore, the importance of a full legal analysis, negotiations and documentation of agreements cannot be overestimated. This method increases efficiency and protects capital from any external or internal crises.

The company's experience confirms that preparing a shareholder agreement when establishing an enterprise in the People's Republic of China requires a combination of legal skills and deep knowledge of the national business tradition. We provide qualified support for the formation of a Shareholder Agreement in China - from initial planning to the moment the regulation acquires mandatory legal force. Specialists allow you to exclude standard miscalculations and create prerequisites under which the agreement functions as an effective management tool, and not a formal declaration. Providing such a service is of particular importance for foreign investors, since it makes it possible to build commercial activities in the PRC on a reliable basis, retain management and ensure stable growth.